I have never encountered anyone who thinks Creed is just “OK”. It’s one extreme or the other. As you can see from all of the reviews here, people either love them or hate them. This CD is a decent compilation of the band’s music. Would like to have seen “In America” from My Own Prison included.
I won’t try to talk any of the Creed haters out of their opinions, that would be a waste of time, but…if they hate the band so much, why would they buy a greatest hits compilation? If they haven’t, why waste their time reviewing it??? Their are plenty of bands I don’t care for, but if I haven’t bought the CD, I don’t waste my time reviewing it.